Travis: I think most Christians are practical cessationists. They have never manifested the miraculous gifts, or seen them manifested, and probably (prior to the Charismatic movement of the last few centuries) never even think about it. But we are extremely reluctant say “God can’t or won’t do such and such” when it appears (in our view) that the bible doesn’t clearly support it. We are also reluctant to label all our Charismatic brethren as:

Liars, or
Demon possessed, or
Mentally self deluded

Which I believe are the only 3 options if cessationism is true.